Up here the pattern of failures is different from the valley. The tank is rarely the first thing to go wrong. Water lines on slopes, plumbing in crawl spaces and units in unheated outbuildings take the winter damage, and the heater inherits the symptoms.
Winter damage has a signature
A split pipe shows up as water where no water should be, often on the first hard morning, sometimes as a hiss behind a wall. A frozen but intact line shows up as a tap that runs nothing.
The heater's part in this is the part worth knowing: an element that ran while the tank was draining can fail, and a gas unit that has been flooded at the base is not relit until it is assessed. So the sequence on a winter call is to isolate, protect the heat source, then repair the line and refill before the appliance is restored.
The emergency page holds the shutdown order for a frozen or burst line.
The supply leaves sediment, not scale
The mutual's water is bought and treated, and it is softer than the groundwater the valley's wells produce, so heavy scale is less of a story here. What does accumulate is sediment: fine material from a distribution system that has been in the ground a long time, settling on the tank floor over the years.
The drain tells you which you have. A slow drain with grit in the bucket means a flush interval shorter than a manufacturer's brochure would suggest, and the maintenance page explains how that interval is read rather than assumed.
Where a property sits outside the mutual's area and runs its own well, the picture inverts: minerals and iron return, and the well's check valve makes expansion a live question.
The relief valve is usually telling the truth
A drip at the discharge tube is not the valve misbehaving. On a closed system, heated water has to go somewhere, and the expansion tank is what absorbs it. A service connection closed against backflow is as much a closed system as a well is.
Two checks settle it: whether an expansion tank is fitted and charged, and whether the drip tracks the heating cycle. If it does both, the answer is expansion capacity, and replacing the valve is a repair that was never going to hold.
No hot water, and nothing leaking
Four causes account for most of these calls: the gas is off or the pilot will not hold, the breaker has tripped, a thermostat or limit has failed, or the tank is empty because something upstream stopped filling it. That last one is worth ruling out before anything else, because a dry tank with the power on becomes a replacement.
What the visit needs
The street and the slope, because a lot below road level changes what can be carried and how long the visit takes. Whether the property is on the mutual or a well. Whether the fuel is piped gas or a propane tank. What the water is doing now, and when it last behaved normally.
That is enough to arrive with the right parts, which matters when the nearest yard is down in the valley. The hub page explains the supply and the winter pattern in more detail.